Quantitative studies | |||||||
Author/year/country | Study type | Aim of the study | Setting | Sample | Method of data collection | Outcomes measures | Quality |
Aho et al. (2011) [40], Finland | RCT Follow-up program vs. usual care | To evaluate a bereavement follow-up intervention for fathers, by comparing grief reactions and to explore their experiences with the program | Intensive care unit, maternity ward, and emergencyroom in five university medical centres | Fathers of children who died at age ≤ 3 years | 1. Hogan Grief Reactions Checklist 2. Questionnaire measuring social support provided by HCPs and peer supporters 3. Questionnaire measuring fathers experience with the follow-up program | 1. Despair, panic behaviour, personal growth, blame and anger, detachment, disorganisation. 2. Affect, affirmation, aid from HCPs and peer supporters 3. The implementation of the program | 2 out of 7 |
Meert et al. (2014) [41], USA | Observational study | To evaluate the feasibility and perceived benefits of conducting physician-parent follow-up meetings | Seven children’s hospitals, oncology units | Critical care physicians, bereaved parents of children who have died in the PICU, relevant others | Survey (items on Likert scale and open-ended questions) | 1. Physician adherence to the framework 2. Experiences with follow-up meeting | 4 out of 7 |
Nikkola et al. (2013) [42], Finland | Observational study | To describe mothers’ experiences with the bereavement follow-up program | Intensive care unit, maternity ward, and emergencyroom in five university medical centres | Mothers of children who died at age ≤ 3 years | 1. Questionnaire measuring social support provided by HCPs and peer supporters 2. Questionnaire measuring mothers experience with the follow-up program | 1. Affect, affirmation, aid. 2. The implementation of the program | 5 out of 7 |
Raitio et al. (2015) [43], Finland | RCT Follow-up program vs. usual care | To explore the effects of a bereavement follow-up intervention on mothers’ grief | Five university medical centres | Mothers of children who died at age ≤ 3 years | 1. Hogan Grief Reactions Checklist | 1. Despair, panic behaviour, personal growth, blame and anger, detachment, disorganisation. | 2 out of 7 |
Qualitative studies | |||||||
Author/year/country | Study type | Aim of the study | Setting | Sample | Method of data collection | Outcomes | Quality |
Aho et al. (2011) [44], Finland | Generic qualitative study | To evaluate the experiences and suggestions for further improvement of a bereavement follow-up program intervention | Perinatal and neonatal units | HCPs who were appointed to care for a child who died at age ≤ 3 years | Open-ended questionnaire and individual telephone interviews | 1. Experiences with the bereavement follow-up program 2. Ideas to improve the bereavement follow-up program | 14,5 out of 32 |
Berrett-Abebe et al. (2017) [45], USA | Generic qualitative study | To understand parents’ experiences with participation in a hospital-based bereavement support program following the loss of a child to cancer | Tertiary care centre, Department of paediatric haematology/oncology | Parents of children who have died of cancer | Focus group | 1. Experiences with medical team during child’s illness 2. Experiences with bereavement follow-up program after child’s death 3. Experiences of other bereavement support | 19,5 out of 32 |
Brink et al. (2016) [46], Denmark | Generic qualitative study | To explore parents’ experience of a follow-up meeting | University hospital, Paediatric Intensive Care Unit | Parents of children (aged 0–16) who have died in the PICU | Individual face-to-face interview | 1. Experiences around a follow-up meeting | 19 out of 32 |
Darbyshire et al. (2012) [47], Australia | Generic qualitative study | To explore the experiences of parents who participated in a nurse-led telephone follow-up support program in paediatric oncology. | Regional women’s & children’s hospital, paediatric oncology unit | Parents of children who have died from an oncology-related condition | Individual face-to-face interview | 1. Experiences with a follow-up support program | 21 out of 32 |
Eggly et al. (2011) [48], USA | Generic qualitative study | To describe a framework to assist PICU physicians in conducting follow-up meetings | Seven children’s hospitals, oncology units | Critical care physicians and bereaved parents whose children died in the PICU | Individual interviews by telephone | 1. Experiences with follow-up meetings | 8 out of 32 |
Meert et al. (2011) [49], USA | Generic qualitative study | To investigate physicians’ experiences and perspectives regarding follow-up meetings | Seven children’s hospitals, oncology units. | Critical care physicians | Individual interviews by telephone | 1. Experiences with follow-up meetings 2. Ideas for future follow-up meetings | 17 out of 32 |
Mixed method study | |||||||
Author/year/country | Study type | Aim of the study | Setting | Sample | Method of data collection | Outcomes | Quality |
Michelson et al. (2013) [50], USA | Mixed method study | To describe implementation of, reflections on, and address barriers for a PICU bereavement photography program, according to HCPs | Children’s hospital, PICU | HCPs who cared for children at PICU who met one of following criteria: impending death, planned withdrawal of life-sustaining therapies with an expectation of a sudden death, examination consistent with brain death | Questionnaires (closed and open-ended questions) | 1. Experiences with a bereavement photography program 2. Ideas to improve the program | 4 out of 7 15,5 out of 32 |
Oliver et al. (2001) [51], USA | Mixed method study | To explore experiences with a bereavement support program | Regional children’s hospital, paediatric trauma centre | Families of children who have died in the paediatric trauma centre and parental supporters | Survey and individual interview | 1. Experiences with a bereavement support program | 4 out of 7 10 out of 32 |
Descriptive articles | |||||||
Author/year/country | Study type | Aim of the study | Setting | Target population | Method of data collection | Outcomes | Quality |
Aho et al. (2010) [52], Finland | Descriptive article | To describe the development and implementation of a bereavement follow-up intervention for grieving fathers | Five university medical centres, perinatal and neonatal unit | Fathers of children who died at age 3 or younger | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Cook et al. (2002) [53], UK | Descriptive article | To review local bereavements support practices over the last 5 years | Regional hospital, PICU | Parents of children who have died unexpectedly in the PICU | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Edi-Osagie et al. (2005) [59], UK | Descriptive article | To describe a template for a bereavement service | Tertiary care centre, NICU | Parents of children who have died in the NICU | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Gibson et al. (2011) [60], USA | Descriptive article | To describe the development of a NICU bereavement program | University hospital, NICU | Parents of children who have died in the NICU | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Levick et al. (2017) [54], USA | Descriptive article | To summarize and evaluate a comprehensive approach of bereavement services to NICU families and education/support to NICU staff | Regional children’s hospital, NICU | Parents of children who have died in the NICU | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Morris et al. (2016) [55], USA | Descriptive article | To discuss the goals of bereavement care and the need to standardize bereavement care in the paediatric setting, and describe their hospital wide bereavement model | Hospital, paediatric setting | Families of children who have died in a paediatric setting | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Reilly-Smorawski et al. (2010) [56], USA | Descriptive article | To evaluate experiences of both individuals and couples with a bereavement support group | Tertiary Centre, NICU | Parents of new-borns or infants who have died in the NICU. | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Snaman et al. (2017) [57], USA | Descriptive article | To review the three primary pillars of a parent-inspired and parent-derived bereavement program | University children’s hospital, oncology and palliative care unit | Parents of children who have died of cancer | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |
Stastny et al. (2016) [58], USA | Descriptive article | To provide a practical guideline for public health nurses (PHN) in performing home visits to bereaved parents | Home visits | Parents of children who have died of sudden infant death syndrome | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. |