Skip to main content

Table 1 Typology of the included manuscripts

From: Noninvasive monitoring technologies to identify discomfort and distressing symptoms in persons with limited communication at the end of life: a scoping review

 

Number of manuscripts

Percentage

Languages

 English

220

96%

 Chinese

4

2%

 Dutch

2

1%

 Japanese

2

1%

 German

1

 < 1%

Countries

 United States of America

63

28%

 Canada

13

6%

 Netherlands

12

5%

 Italy

11

5%

 France

9

4%

 Germany

9

4%

 Japan

9

4%

 Australia

8

3%

 United Kingdom

8

3%

 Belgium

7

3%

 China

7

3%

 South Korea

7

3%

 Finland

5

2%

 Spain

5

2%

 Switzerland

3

1%

 Brazil

2

1%

 Denmark

2

1%

 India

2

1%

 Greece

2

1%

 Mexico

2

1%

 New Zealand

2

1%

 Portugal

2

1%

 Singapore

2

1%

 Other countries

8

3%

 Two or more countriesa

29

13%

Year of publication

 1991–1995

4

2%

 1996–2000

13

6%

 2001–2005

15

7%

 2006–2010

31

14%

 2011–2015

41

18%

 2016–2020

79

25%

 2021-2023b

46

20%

Monitoring technologies

 Actigraphy

57

25%

 Brain activity monitors

25

11%

  Bispectral Index (BIS)

15

 

  Other Electroencephalography (EEG)-basedc, d

9

 

  Sedation monitor (concept)

1

 

 Electrocardiography (ECG)c

12

5%

 Electrodermal activity (EDA) monitor

8

3%

 Surface electromyogram (sEMG)

2

1%

 Incontinence sensors

11

5%

 Multi-modal systemse

96

42%

  Polysomnography (PSG)

75

 

  With environmental sensors

6

 

  Other multi-modal systems

14

 

 Non-contact monitoring systems f

21

9%

  Pressure mats

9

 

  Video/facial expression analysis

4

 

  Infrared

2

 

  Radar

3

 

  Multiple sensors

3

 

Aim of studiesg

 No technology-related aims (the technology is applied as standard measurement)

91

39%

 Development of the technology

38

17%

 Feasibility/pilot study of the technology

51

22%

 Validation of the technology

65

28%

  1. Total number of included manuscripts = 229
  2. aThe main countries involved were the USA (11 manuscripts), China (8 manuscripts), Finland (6 manuscripts), and the Netherlands (6 manuscripts). The countries involved in specific manuscripts can be found in etables 1–3 in the supplements
  3. bManuscripts published before March 13, 2023 were included
  4. c3 manuscripts used both Electroencephalography and Electrocardiography to monitor people under sedation
  5. dOther electroencephalogram-based technologies refer to traditional EEGs and other technologies which use EEG electrodes
  6. eMulti-modal systems use a combination of different technologies within one integrated system or algorithm
  7. fNon-contact monitoring systems use sensors that do not have direct contact with the person being monitored
  8. g16 articles had multiple aims